2 heroines in love with the same hero - relating ( singing) their respective woes
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The MDs involved in each : Pt Govindram; Anil Biswas; Naushad & G.Ramanathan resptly
After listening to all of them intently - without any prejudice towards any of them - I have sincerely felt that G.Ramanathan has SCORED BETTER in terms of imparting melodic novelty in the emotional song. The brief 'aalaps' by P.Leela & Jikki in turn are a treat to listen...highlighting their respective emotions.
GR always used to like the creations of MD : Naushad. Why ? He used to say that they were very simple in structure. In the concerned Tamil song, the orchestration has been done in Naushad's style .
Second comes Pt Govindram for his presentation wherein Zohrabai redeems her rendering class on the higher scale. The orchestration is smooth flowing and harmonius melodically.Rajkumari's rendition , in contrast has been sober and subdued.
Third ranks Anil Biswas. Ramsingh's saxaphone pieces alone, add lustre to the overall melody. Without that ... just imagine ! The song is simple in style . Lata's voice quality/timbre thence, was the FINEST of her entire career.
Fourth goes to Naushad - Simple composition and soulfully emoted by both, Shamshad & Lata.
The fourth song is uploaded in the next blog for want of space
21, December, 2014
Send feedback / comments to : sjhhhtm@gmail.com
No comments:
Post a Comment